California Pre-Claim Review Explained: What Home Health Agencies Must Do Before Jan 18

Featuring Jay Duty

About This Episode

Transcript

Tom Maxwell (00:15)

All right. Welcome back to the Last Visit First podcast bonus editions. Today we're going to talk about the pre-claim review that's coming out in California. CMS just announced that they're going to bring the pre-claim review that was in Ohio and Florida and a few other states to California. Happy to welcome back the expert in this stuff. With me is Jay Duty. He's the chief operating officer at Maxwell TEC. Jay and I are going to walk through what agencies need to do to get ready for pre-claim review in California. So let's jump in. We've got a couple of slides we're going to go through, then we'll talk about some of the lessons learned from Ohio and Florida and what's going to happen there, and then we'll talk about how we can help and what you need to be ready for. So I'm going to pop up a slide deck for you and we'll jump in. So the first thing we've got to do is make a choice. Select Choice 1, pre-claim review, during the California selection window. You've got to send every request before the final claim and bill only with unique tracking numbers, and hold 90% affirmation on 10 requests or more for a six-month period. So that's going to be super important. The selection window is for January 2027. From November 16th to December 16th, you need to make your selection. If you don't make your selection, they'll make it for you. On January 18th, 2027, which is a weird date that they chose, but that's the date they chose, the billing periods starting on or after that date are when California agencies need to either do pre-claim or post-claim. And your MAC is J6, which is Wellpoint Federal. They receive these requests and issue decisions for California. So most important, you need to make your selection between pre-payment or post-payment. An agency that makes no selection is assigned to Choice 2, postpayment review. So here are your options. It's either pre-claim or post-claim. So which one do you want? Pre-claim is you send documentation before you bill. A decision is made within 10 business days, and you have to bill with a unique tracking number. They'll actually ask you to put that tracking number onto your claims, and gaps are fixed before the claim exists. If you choose postpayment, which is the default, not the one we recommend, then every claim in this cycle is paid and then pulled for review. So 100% of your claims are going to be pulled for review. That gives you no ability to correct a problem. If you put in a pre-claim and there's a problem, you can correct it. With postpayment, they have 45 days to answer each one of these record requests. And then the MAC has 60 days to decide whether they're going to pay you or not. Denied claims are recouped, which means they actually recoup it from your payments going forward. So you've got to figure out, do you want Choice 1 or Choice 2? Choose nothing, you get Choice 2. The trade-off is certainty. Supporters of the pre-claim option say it lets the agency fix that documentation before billing, and it avoids denials arriving a month later. If you want to do it as you're getting ready to bill, you do pre-claim. If you want to fix all the problems after and get denials, do post-claim. Most agencies choose pre-claim. 64% chose pre-claim, and 97% of pre-claim requests are affirmed. So you're only talking about 3% of your claims that are not affirmed. And once you get to that 90% threshold, they change the process for you. On this slide, we're talking about a central process that costs real review time. At 1,000 ADC, we think you're going to do about 12,167 reviews. In California, it's every 30 days. It takes about 30 to 45 minutes for each one of these patients to be reviewed. You start looking at the amount of staff hours, and it's about 6,000 to 9,000 staff hours a year that are going to be involved in this process. You do the math on that at 30 bucks an hour, it's about $182,000. At 45 bucks an hour, it's $273,000. If it takes you 45 minutes, it's $273,000 or $410,000. So how much money do you want to spend on this? This is going to be a little bit of a challenge, but you don't want to get all your claims denied. So how a pre-claim request works: you submit one 30-day billing period per request in California, before the final claim. You submit it, and the MAC has 10 business days to make a decision on that unique tracking number. If it's not affirmed, you have to fix the gaps and resubmit it. They actually give you a non-affirmed number as well when you submit it. And then you bill your final claim. So that's the pre-claim workflow. What goes into a pre-claim package? There's the patient: Medicare number, date of birth, all that stuff. The certifying practitioner: the doctor, the NPI, the address. Your agency: your NPI, your CMS certification number, your PTAN, phone, address and all that. And then all the medical record support for why you support this patient. Are they homebound and under a physician's care? Was the plan of care reviewed by the physician? Is there a skilled need? Is there a face-to-face encounter? It's all the things you're normally doing today, but you're putting this together in a pre-claim package to make sure you're going to get paid for that episode. There are three possible outcomes. You get a provisional affirmation: good to go, green light. You get non-affirmed: red light, you didn't get affirmed and you have to resubmit or correct the problems. Or you get rejected: the MAC couldn't process the request, for example invalid beneficiary data, or a patient already covered by another agency. You won't get an affirmation on that. And you're looking for affirmations. You have to bill with the tracking number. On the claim there's a specific tracking number, one per agency per patient. It's good to keep a list of those, or there's a way in your EMR to manage those as well. How do you get to 90%? A 90% full affirmation rate is needed. Only fully affirmed decisions count. If you get a non-affirmation, that doesn't count toward your 90%, and you have to get to 90% in order to get off of pre-claim or post-claim. You have to have at least 10 requests in the six-month cycle for the rate to qualify for that provider number. And 30 days after the cycle ends, the MAC will tell you your rate and whether you're affirmed and can get off of pre-claim or post-claim. This is a requirement, guys. You can't get out of this one. What does it take to pass? What do you need to do every time? You need a valid plan of care with physician orders. You need a face-to-face encounter within 90 days before or 30 days after the start of care. You need documented homebound status. You need a documented skilled need. Physician care has to be documented. Use your MAC's checklist. We can provide you that checklist from your J6 MAC. What to avoid? Billing with no decision on file. Don't do that. The claim stops for prepayment review, and if payable takes a 25% cut that cannot be appealed or billed to the patient. That's a problem. Incomplete packets. If you don't do a good job of this, you're going to have incomplete packets and problems. Billing a non-affirmed request will create a denial on your claim. They're putting processes in place at the MAC to make sure you're doing this correctly. Jay, talk to us about some lessons that we learned from Ohio and Florida as we went through this process.

Jay (07:21)

Yeah, so just to bring in some history here, obviously Ohio and Florida have run this process longer than anyone. They have a different contractor than California is going to have, so some of these results may vary because they're administered a little bit differently. But the pattern of the problems that everybody sees is pretty consistent. So basically those experiences are going to provide free education for what you're going to see in California. It starts with documentation, because that's where the requests are going to die, right? The face-to-face note is missing, the encounter falls outside the window, maybe the visit doesn't support the main reason for the care, the plan of care wasn't complete, or an old admission defect haunts the later periods. Every one of these is preventable with a completeness check. Make sure you're looking at those claims before they're submitted, and walking through step by step. You should look at the history of what you've been doing in these different areas. Again, a missing face-to-face note is a big driver of all of this, so make sure you're taking that into account and learning from this history. More of those issues are signatures. These are the things you commonly see anytime you're QAing these charts. Documentation quality matters a lot with physician orders as well. If your homebound language is too generic, if it's not really speaking to a clear reason for homebound status, things like "taxing effort" with nothing specific about the patient, that weak documentation, in addition to chasing signatures, is going to kick those out. None of this is exotic or crazy. This is all just blocking and tackling that you need to do. And the agencies that are going to win here are the ones that have assigned owners to each one of these pieces. Next, what happens after you submit? If you're getting repeated non-affirmations, you're going to be eating up a lot of staff time. Tom showed you the cost and the time there. There are tools out there to help with these reviews, so that's something you might consider. But if you're spending the time resending that same packet over and over again, that's lots of administrative time. You may be hiring a bank of quality reviewers, and those are real dollars. In Ohio and Florida, even the agencies that were performing well reported a big administrative burden, because they're paying reviewers to look at all these charts. They make sure everybody is assigned a UTN and it's correct, in addition to the documentation being there. What we see, Tom, is most of these agencies have some quality review process, QA nurses taking a look at this too. But you've got to make sure you're not making those mistakes in the midst of submitting for that affirmation. That's the difference. When you QA these after the care, more time has passed and you've got more time to get the physician documentation in place and the face-to-face encounter in place. This is early on in that period. So you've got to make sure the documentation is not only buttoned up like you would normally submit or QA a claim, but done early in the process to make sure you get that UTN. You've got to make sure that's included and tied there too.

Tom Maxwell (10:47)

Yeah, so there are three types of payment traps. No request, you get a 20% cut. Partial affirmations cause you a problem and keep you in this process longer. And then provisional status: an affirmation is provisional. The final claim still has to meet all the Medicare requirements. Just because you get an affirmation, when you submit your final claim, they can still ask you to produce all this again. So again, the purpose of this is to do the pre-claim and get yourself to 90%, so you can take this burden away. There are a lot of staffing and management challenges. Admin work competes with patient care. You're spending all your time getting everything ready to go and checking it, double-checking it, quadruple-checking it. There's a steep learning curve. Most agencies have a lot of this stuff, but figuring out how to submit these, how to wait for the affirmation, and how to make sure you continue to provide great patient care while you're waiting on affirmation is a big deal. Missing a selection or deadline is really a problem too, so you want to make sure you have a good process set up. A lot of agencies had trouble reaching the 90% threshold, and they were spending a lot more intensity around that, putting more people on it. You have to monitor your performance through each of the cycles. And then there are outdated instructions. There are a lot of older articles and retired choices out there, so verify the choices against CMS and your current MAC. The threshold is generally 90% with at least 10 requests. That's the challenge. If you have fewer than 10 patients, then you don't have to do this. But if you have more than 10, you've got to get at least 10 in there and be at 90% on those. So nine out of 10. Some of the facts in Ohio were really interesting. A provider reported high affirmation rates, but called Ohio's reviews stricter than its Illinois experience. Illinois is another pre-claim review state. We highlighted these two because they're the bigger ones. One of the providers said Ohio was harder than Illinois, so now California is going to be harder than Ohio and Florida. A Florida provider, and this is just some data I pulled from the web, said experienced agencies established a process and mostly met isolated issues. Preparation and repetition reduce disruption. So make sure you're prepped and ready to go and understand how to do this. Again, if you need help, Jay will tell you how we can help you at the end. A really large provider described continuing administrative costs despite strong review performance. They did a good job on their affirmation rate, but they still had to spend the money to do it. And COVID was going on when all of the pre-claim review was coming out too, so COVID delays and phased implementation changed deadlines and transition instructions. They delayed this a little bit in Florida during the COVID timeframe, so that was a real challenge as well. Two findings in perspective: CMS reported a 97% affirmation rate for completed pre-claim review requests. That's a really high number, but there was a lot of effort and work that went into getting to that 97%. The other thing that's really interesting is that Health Affairs did a study in 2026 that found no statistically significant spending reduction attributed to the program in Ohio or Florida. So all of this was to get the fraud out and do a better job, and there was no statistically significant spending reduction. Running that pre-claim review process in your EMR is really important. So how do you do it? Where do you do it? I'm going to walk you through a few steps. EMR tools have a PCR console. A lot of people have something called a pre-claim review console or pre-claim review screens, depending on which EMR you have. There are specific workflow tasks, and if you turn those on in your EMR, it'll actually kick off that pre-claim review workflow for you. If you don't understand what we're talking about, call us, ask us, and we'll help you with that. You have to do an electronic submission of these, and there's an electronic submission interface you can use. I'm going to talk to you a little bit about tools we know in the industry. We've partnered with a company called Element5, and in a minute we'll talk about how they can make that process really easy for you. But you do have to submit it, then wait your 10 days, and make sure it's affirmed. Then you have to load that back into your EMR before you bill. Automating that process will make it much easier, I promise you. Task one is you get your face-to-face documentation, you get everything ready for the episode, get your plan of care ready to go, get your current episode ready to go, make sure you have the right data and documentation, and then you load those all together into a packet and submit it. Some of the staffing habits that have worked: splitting the roles. The clinician enters eligibility documentation and reviews the chart. Non-clinical staff handle submission and resubmission. So you don't have to have nurses do all of this. You can have trained staff who are non-clinicians handle that. Always make sure you review clinically first. Download the packet and red-box the key criteria you're looking for. Assign one login per branch PTAN. This is a really important piece too. Make sure you have control around this. If it's completely centralized, make sure you understand who controls it and who's sending the claims. If you're doing it decentralized, assign one login per branch PTAN. And then track your write-offs. If you're not affirmed and you can't get paid for those, you want to make sure you track those as well. So Element5 is really interesting. They've automated the entire package. Element5 is a robotic process automation company that we partner with at Maxwell TEC when we're helping customers do this. Once you get the claim and everything ready to go, think about them as the transportation mechanism. They log into your EMR with robotic process automation, with agentic AI that goes and grabs all the documentation and requirements you tell it to. They send that across to the fiscal intermediary, and they know it's 10 days, so they go back, log back in, get the affirmations and pull those back for you. We'll walk through that process a little bit here. Manual submission is an administrative burden. It takes a bunch of time, it's done by hand, it takes hours, and you're constantly checking a portal. With the Element5 approach, they manage the workflow between the EMR and the MAC. They submit and resubmit, monitor daily and pull down your decisions, as we talked about. It follows that six-step process. You see one, two, three, four, five, six. When the automation starts, there's a "ready for submission" flag that's set in your EMR. The scope is initial submissions and resubmissions. The cadence: your EMR is checked for eligible records daily. It looks at those and asks, is it ready? Is it time to send these? If yes, it sends them to the fiscal intermediary. Your team manages just the exceptions. You still have to do all the clinical support and the work, making sure the face-to-face is all there. But when it's ready to be submitted, you don't have somebody logging in and waiting for those affirmations. That's really the automation. They submit to the MAC, capture the DCN, the document control number, and then capture the UTN, the unique tracking number, for each one of those. They download the decision letters and drop those back in your EMR. That's the most important piece. They upload the decision letter through the RPA and attach it in your EMR. It's super important for you to think about automating this process. They have a hub in the Element5 tool that helps you track and manage these. It has a transaction ID, the patient, the submission type, resubmissions, and graphics that show you how your organization is doing. So a CEO, CFO or COO trying to manage this has dashboards and graphics, and you're not having to pull reports and roll those up yourself. It's really going to help you as you create this new process inside your organization. Proven results: in Illinois, Florida and Ohio, they've shown a 50% reduction in time on the claim, because they're pulling all the information for you and telling you which ones need work. Most of their affirmations are in the 98th to 99th percentile, so really high. So if you want to get past this pretty quickly, you want to partner with Element5 and Maxwell TEC. And 100% efficient task completion. They're doing that work, and anytime it fails, they let you know. They did a case study with a home health and hospice group that did this. The challenge was that they were projecting 175 to 200 hours a week supporting pre-claim review, and they narrowed that down very quickly and reduced the number of hours spent. They reduced it from $182,000 to $91,000. The difference in California is they need a request for every 30 days, so volume is going to be high and repetitive. Again, this is an administrative task. It's going to be really painful for you. Once you pass, there are three options. Choice 1: stay on pre-claim review for another six months. Fall below 90% and you return to the initial choices. Choice 3: selective postpayment review by random sampling every six months, permanent for the rest of the demonstration. Choice 4: a spot check of a random 5% of claims before payment. Keep 90% approval to stay. So once you get past 90%, you fall into one of these three choices. Now your readiness plan. This is your call to action. By November 16th, you need to confirm each PTAN and prepare for Choice 1 if you want Choice 1. I highly recommend that. Check your claims before you send them versus having them all reviewed after you send them. By December 16th, you have to submit your selection with Wellpoint Federal and keep proof of that. In December, you've got to train your intake team on how to do this process, train your clinical team on how to review these, and train your billing staff on the request flow. You need to sign a contract with Element5 if you want to do the automation. We can help you do that really easily. And then on January 18th, you're going live. They have not put a delay on this yet, and I don't see them putting a delay on it. In Florida, Ohio and Illinois, they delayed it. I think California is going to push this forward. But if something changes, we'll absolutely keep you updated. So January 18th is your go-live date. That's 51 days till the end of the year, plus 18 days, so you have about 69 or 70 days before you have to make this decision. So get ready. If you want to read the source, here's where we got it from: the CMS Home Health Review Choice Demonstration Operational Guide. I pulled this in for you. Chapters 5 through 12 cover the selection, so if you want to look at that, you can. With all that being said, Jay, if someone wants some help, how do they find you?

Jay (21:18)

Reach out to us at sales@maxwelltec.com for information on that. Obviously our recommendation here is pre-claim review. There are several ways we can help with that. Yes, you need to get automation in place. We can also help you project manage this. There's a lot at stake. You've got to get to that second set of choices, right? So make your choice on Choice 1. But after you pass, this is all about performance. If you perform well during that period, you're going to have a lot more flexibility in how you go forward, which will take away some of that administrative burden too. So reach out to us, we'd love to help you do this. We've also got people and consultants who can do this for you, who can look at those claims and make sure everything's buttoned up and ready for pre-claim review. It depends on how you want to approach it. One thing we worry about is that your staff may be distracted doing some of this administrative work when they really need to be focusing on patient care, or you may not have a bank of reviewers for this short period of time. So reach out to us, we're happy to help. We can help you figure out how to automate it. We can project manage the process. We can help you actually staff putting those through pre-claim review, and help you with the choices and optimize your processes to make sure you're getting these claims through. Again, in California it's going to be each one of those 30-day periods, so there's a lot to do, and then you get the chance to do it again. So you really need to think about how you make that process repeatable. We'd love to help. Reach out to us at sales@maxwelltec.com. Yeah, that's great, Jay. And thank you all for joining us. Sorry this is going on in your world. For those of you in California who watch this podcast, or if you have agencies with branches in California, you've got to change your process. Imagine you're a national agency, you're really big, and you have a small branch or a few branches in California. You're now having to do pre-claim for some of your claims and not the rest of them. If you're in Florida, Illinois, Ohio and California, you're doing it for all your patients, but if you're not, you're going to have a subset of things you have to do.

Tom Maxwell (23:24)

So Maxwell TEC would love to help you. On the Last Visit First podcast, we're going to continue to do these bonus episodes. This is our way of trying to quickly get you some information, give you some slides, give you our recommendations, work with some of the partners we work with, and hopefully let you know what's going on in the industry. You can always reach out to me on the Last Visit First podcast. Subscribe to this, and please share it with your friends in California. If there are people out there who haven't been aware of this, please share this podcast. This is how we make content like this. And I appreciate you listening to us.

All episodes