From the DOJ to the Defense Table: What Hospice Operators Need to Hear

Featuring Jonathan Porter

About This Episode

Transcript

Tom Maxwell (00:14)

Today I have a distinguished guest that I think most people in the hospice industry are going to want to listen to. Jonathan Porter is a partner at Husch Blackwell, one of the sharpest minds in healthcare enforcement law. He's a former prosecutor and assistant United States attorney. Jonathan spent years at the Department of Justice taking down hospice fraud and healthcare fraud schemes involving billions in billings. Now he flips the script, defending hospices, home health agencies, health systems, and healthcare executives navigating False Claims Act investigations. Chambers USA calls him a superstar and clients say he always has the bigger picture. He also hosts a podcast called False Claims Act Insights and teaches white collar crime at Mercer University School of Law. Jonathan, welcome to the podcast.

Jonathan Porter (00:59)

Tom, thanks for having me. This is exciting.

Tom Maxwell (01:01)

Yeah, it is going to be fun. All right, take us back to the beginning. Talk about the early moments in your career that got you into where you're at today.

Jonathan Porter (01:07)

Yeah, thanks. The path towards where I am now, you know, I always knew I wanted to help people. There's something about my personality where I really enjoy helping people. I didn't really know what that was going to look like. I didn't know that it was going to be as a lawyer, but I did find out recently, since my mom passed away a couple of years ago, we've been cleaning out some stuff from the house my dad lives in, and I found this book from when I was a kid that said that I was going to be a trial lawyer one day. And so I guess I knew what I was doing from an early age. But yeah, that's how I got here.

Tom Maxwell (01:43)

That's awesome. So you went to Furman University for undergrad and then Emory for law. What drew you to law? What do you think? I mean, he started out as a kid thinking about law, but what really drew you into that? And then how'd you get to healthcare law?

Jonathan Porter (01:55)

Yeah, good questions, Tom. With law, it really was an extension of my desire to help people with hard things. I like digging into hard things. I did a personality test when I worked in DC after undergrad. Between undergrad and law school, I worked in DC. I worked on Capitol Hill. We did a personality test up there with my member of Congress that I worked for. My personality test came back really weird. It said that my attention to detail in times of crisis is through the roof. So what I do now is help people through times of crisis, so it actually works out really, really well. I went to law school because I love helping people with hard things. And so that's where I am. The healthcare thing was actually sort of bizarre. I had no intention of going into healthcare. I knew I wanted to be an assistant United States attorney. I met a guy when I was in law school who helped with Emory Law's trial techniques program, and he was a federal prosecutor. He just raved about the calling that is being a federal prosecutor. And so I knew I wanted to go to the Justice Department. I knew I wanted to be a federal prosecutor. When I got there on day one, I had visions of, I'm gonna go stop human traffickers and terrorists and all these people. And I got to the office and they said, great, you're gonna start in healthcare. And I had to Google what the difference between Medicare and Medicaid was. So that was a DOJ decision to start me there. A lot of people started there and then moved into, you know, violent crime or whatever. I loved it. I absolutely fell in love with healthcare as a need for all of us. The weird role that it plays in our society where the government pays for a lot of it, but not all of it. How there are these interesting things in healthcare where you're not allowed to actually profit off of the full value that someone brings. There's a bunch of stuff within healthcare that really spoke to me as important and nuanced. DOJ told me I was going to be a healthcare lawyer and I fell in love with it from there, but I had no intention of going into healthcare before that.

Tom Maxwell (04:09)

Yeah, so you spent most of your career prosecuting doctors, pharmacists, executives, even a pastor for white collar crimes. What did that work teach you about human behavior and decision making under pressure?

Jonathan Porter (04:20)

Yeah, there's a lot of fraud out there. There's a lot of knowing fraud out there, people who go out and they say, I'm gonna go commit all of the fraud. I want to commit fraud. Think about COVID fraud, the sort of text messages that we saw from people's phones during the COVID pandemic after the CARES Act was passed, showed people knew exactly what they were doing. There's a lot of people out there who want to go into the fraud world. I mean, you read about a lot of this on the news, people who want to commit fraud. And there's a lot of that in healthcare as well. One of my FBI agents that I worked with a lot at DOJ, he was undercover once in this meeting of marketers who were gonna go door to door in a genetic testing scheme. He was undercover pretending to be someone who's gonna go door to door. And they're prepping all the people to go door to door to swab cheeks and stuff for genetic testing. And the guy pulls him aside at the end and he said, all right, everything I just said up there was wrong. We're actually going to pay you this way. And he describes a paper swab scheme. But he said, but we can't announce that because that's an illegal kickback. And so we're doing this other thing. I mean, that's someone who understands that he's doing something wrong. That's someone who understands that he's violating a federal law. There's a ton of people out there who know what the law is and intentionally choose to do the wrong thing. But there's also a lot of people out there, and I learned this as a federal prosecutor, there's also a lot of people out there who are trying to do their best and sometimes just get it wrong. And I think it's critical that we think about the difference between those two. On the one hand, the people who know that what they're doing is wrong, and on the other, people who don't know that what they're doing is wrong. They're trying to do well, and maybe they make a judgment call and get it wrong. So the key to me when I was a federal prosecutor was figuring out which cases deserve that big federal hammer and which cases don't. And that's what I love about my job is it's not necessarily always about right and wrong. It's about whether you knew that what you were doing was right or wrong.

Tom Maxwell (06:35)

Tell us about this pastor that did a white collar crime. You don't have to give names, but give us details around that.

Jonathan Porter (06:41)

Yeah, so he committed a good bit of CARES Act fraud. He invented a business, invented some fake tax returns. I think the first thing that he bought with his COVID loan was not in furtherance of any sort of small business, which didn't exist. It was to buy himself a Mercedes. I'm someone who has a great deal of faith and I tend to judge my own kind pretty harshly when they do things they're not supposed to do. So that one really irritated me. Pastors should not invent fake businesses to buy Mercedes with fraudulent proceeds.

Tom Maxwell (07:14)

But it happened. Okay, let's pivot. So you were at the Department of Justice, you were prosecuting people that were committing fraud, and then now you've pivoted your practice and now you're representing the healthcare community as they become scrutinized. So what made you change and talk to us about that.

Jonathan Porter (07:39)

Yeah, so I did change from DOJ to the defense, but in my mind, I don't view it as changing sides or reversing course. You know, when I was at DOJ, I prosecuted knowing fraud. The people who went out there and said, I'm going to go commit all of the fraud today, who know that what I'm about to do is wrong, but I'm going to do that anyway. But what I started seeing was how the False Claims Act, which is a civil law, was being misused to extract really large settlements for conduct that was more in the realm of, you should have known, rather than real fraud. And that concerned me when I was at DOJ and it still does. So largely, Tom, what I do today is I represent healthcare organizations that find themselves under federal investigation. And most of them are in this gray area where the question is whether they knew that what they were doing was improper. And so the move itself has been great. I love Husch Blackwell. It's the number one health law firm in the country. We do a lot of things outside of healthcare law, but our health law team is spectacular in particular. I absolutely love the people I work with. Our clients are great. So I love the move to private practice, I love the chance to get to represent people who are under federal scrutiny that I don't know should be under federal scrutiny.

Tom Maxwell (08:59)

Got it, got it, for sure. So right now this is very timely. The Vice President just suspended 447 hospice practices and 23 home health agencies in the LA area, in California. We're seeing tons and tons of this through Operation Skip Trace. There's been millions and millions and millions of dollars involved. Thoughts around that? What do you do if you're a legitimate hospice agency that gets involved in this or a home health agency that gets involved in this? So let's talk about first the policy and what's kind of going on and then we'll talk about what do you do.

Jonathan Porter (09:31)

Yeah, I mean, there's a lot of pretty extreme fraud that's in the news. And this is actually not new. Several years back, there was a news story in California in particular that talked about how there were a bunch of hospices in California with 100% live discharge rates. I mean, thinking about what hospice is, you go on hospice for end of life, if 100% of your patients' lives don't end, you've got some explaining to do. It's been a problem in California for a while. The issue is it just really hasn't been prosecuted. And so when something isn't prosecuted for a long time, word spreads that you can go make a killing doing this. It's the same thing with the CARES Act. So the reason the CARES Act got ripped off so much was because when the federal government rolled out Hurricane Katrina funding, and yes, Tom, I am old enough to remember Hurricane Katrina,

Tom Maxwell (10:31)

Me too.

Jonathan Porter (10:32)

the problem there was it really was not prosecuted all that much. There were some scattered prosecutions, but there were a lot of people who knew that that Katrina relief got ripped off and that emboldened people to rip off PPP, EIDL, all of these CARES Act things during COVID. It's the same thing in healthcare. When hospices are able to do things for a long period of time and rip off a lot of people, more and more people are going to arrive in that space as they hear, hey, this is a vulnerable program. That's what's happening in California. So there's a lot of legitimate enforcement actions that need to happen in California. The issue, Tom, is that not all of this enforcement is going against those egregious actors. Some of this enforcement is going against legitimate hospices, legitimate home health providers where they're doing things the right way. They just happen to be in a state where it's under a lot of scrutiny. And so the big deal here is making sure out of the gate when you're talking with DOJ, when you get a lawyer and the lawyer's talking to DOJ, is framing this as, look at all these bad people over here. There's all these reports. There's Dr. Oz flying to Los Angeles to sit down with community leaders and talk about fraud in the hospice world. That's these people over here. We're not in that world. We're over here in this good world. Why don't you think about spending your time going after the 15 pop-up hospices that all register at the same address that have gotten millions of taxpayer dollars? There's a big difference here. And so it's irritating when DOJ responds to a crisis by lumping all hospices together or all home health agencies together and saying that we're going to go investigate everyone, when there's a set of really bad actors over here and a set of good actors over here. I think there's got to be a lot more effort to differentiate the good from the bad here.

Tom Maxwell (12:35)

And so how do they do that? I mean, I can easily plot every hospice agency in the United States on a map and I can show you where those 15 or 20 or 50 are, or as Nick said, the YouTuber that went out there and knocked on all the doors and said nobody was there. And when they did answer the door, it was one person with a desk and that was it. I mean, I can figure that out in seconds. So why aren't they using those tools versus going and scrutinizing everybody? And by the way, I've gotten a bunch of phone calls from hospices in California that said, hey, we just got a PPOE and they shut us down and they're not going to pay us. And now we've got to prove our innocence, not prove we're guilty. And so they're going to go out of business or they're going to lose money. They're scrambling in a panic. They're saying, what do I do, Tom? And so they're getting tons of ADRs, they're getting tons of PPOEs, they're getting letters of suspension. Why is it so hard for the government to just pinpoint, hey, these are all the guys that we know are going to defraud? They'd have a hundred percent discharge rate, that kind of stuff.

Jonathan Porter (13:30)

Yeah, why is it so hard for the federal government to figure it out? It probably shouldn't be. But one of the things that DOJ and its law enforcement partners have spent a lot of time thinking about is how to make better use of their data. A lot of the stuff is in the data. DOJ has really good access to data. They've got a lot of programs in place to find problematic things quickly. So a lot of this is about making better use of their data. But, Tom, I'll tell you one of the big problems in all of this. On the civil side at least, the Justice Department's agenda is largely driven by qui tam relators, whistleblowers, people who file allegations of fraud under seal and then DOJ goes and investigates, and sometimes it'll be years. The disconnect here, Tom, is that qui tam relators really don't have much of an incentive to go after the fly-by-night pop-up hospice where all the money's been moved to some foreign location already. They're not going to recover anything there because the money's gone. So there's no use spending all this time hiring a lawyer and drafting a qui tam complaint, getting it filed under seal, meeting with the government, giving them all the material facts, all of those things, if you're not going to get any dollars out of it. The way this actually works is qui tam relators and their lawyers are looking for legitimate providers, legitimate hospices, legitimate home health agencies, and saying, DOJ said they're going to go after hospices in California or wherever. Let's go name qui tams against these legitimate providers who have deep pockets. They've got the ability to actually pay funds at the end of this because the relators are going to want to get their attorney's fees paid, all of those things. And so what happens here is you get more action against the good guys than the bad guys because relator lawyers know that they can collect against the good guys and they know they can't against the people who've already moved their money to Eastern Europe or wherever. That's the big disconnect here, the incentives are a little bit off. That's not to say that DOJ doesn't find the fly-by-night operators, they should, but in the mix, it's the legitimate people who seem to get taken down because of the role that whistleblowers play in healthcare enforcement.

Tom Maxwell (15:51)

That one hurts. We need to shut off the fraud. Because the money's already gone and now they're not going to collect their fees, they're going to go fight everybody else that's trying to do the right thing. And really, who is it going to hurt? In the big scheme of things, it's going to hurt the patient. That's a true legit hospice patient that's being cared for and you just shut off the funding for that hospice to be able to do more visits, more care, more chaplains, more social workers, more aides, more supplies, more meds. And so that's going to hurt. So if I'm an agency that just got a letter and they're going to shut me down and essentially turn my billing off and I've got to go produce all these ADRs, which stands for additional documentation requests, and I've got to go send all this documentation in and they're going to scrutinize every single patient that I'm seeing. What do I do? If I'm an operator that doesn't understand this, what do I do? I mean, call Jonathan, right? That's the right answer, but you need to get a lawyer really quickly and you need to get to work.

Jonathan Porter (16:46)

Yeah, yeah, yeah. I hate it when the answer is give me a call because I really don't want to blatantly market myself like that. But you really do need a good lawyer at that point. You need someone who understands all of these processes, who's gone up against the government before. I've had success getting payment suspensions reversed. Payment suspensions, by the way, on the federal level, I mean, this was announced last year that these were coming. Kim Brant, who's one of the senior CMS folks right under Dr. Oz, made an announcement last year saying that she's going to start exercising payment suspensions way more. And so this has been coming. This was not a secret. Those of us who are in the healthcare enforcement world knew that these were coming. The issue is once the dollars are off, it's really hard to get a federal judge involved to get them turned back on because of the way the standards work. It's really bad because there are some stories out there about legitimate healthcare organizations where when the dollars are turned off, if you're like a nonprofit or something like that, how in the world are you gonna stay in business for a year, 18 months while you're fighting a payment suspension, fighting an investigation, getting your lawyers paid? I mean, it's a really dire situation to be in, but that's what's happening for a lot of folks. Now, most of the payment suspensions really are going up against those fly-by-night 15 hospices at one address situations, but it can be really dangerous for a smaller nonprofit hospice that is in it for the right reasons. That's really, really dangerous.

Tom Maxwell (18:29)

And so how long does that process take? From the time you get a letter to the time you get it turned back on, is it years really?

Jonathan Porter (18:37)

Yeah, it depends. I mean, there are some court cases out there that show that it takes years. Sometimes you get lucky and you can get the right meetings and get it done quicker than that. But if there's a credible allegation of fraud and it's a real allegation, you're up against it. The standards are pretty tough and proving your innocence is not easy. And you have to think about the underlying investigation while you're having conversations about the payment suspension. There's a ton of leverage. DOJ already has a ton of leverage in healthcare investigations. When you turn off the money for a community hospital or a mission-driven nonprofit hospice, it's really, really hard. So it could take a while. And unfortunately, DOJ knows that if it takes a while, they're getting more and more leverage, which is really not the way any of this should work except for actual instances of people going out and committing a whole lot of knowing fraud. But yeah, it's tough.

Tom Maxwell (19:42)

So what are the triggers? Just thinking out loud, if I'm a hospice provider, what are some of the trigger points? Is it live discharges, long length of stay, live discharges? Is it eligibility criteria? What are the things that you think the government is really gonna look at and what are the trigger points that would really take a legitimate hospice that's trying to do the right thing and get them into a situation?

Jonathan Porter (20:06)

Yeah, so the stuff in the news should be the trigger for the bad actors. It's the 15 hospices that all enroll on the same day and they're all at the one location. There are some pretty obvious triggers out there. For the legitimate hospices out there, Tom, and I'm feeling that most of your listeners are in the legitimate world, for the legitimate folks, it is your standard long length of stay situations. That is still something that DOJ looks at a lot. They've got some specific tools that DOJ can use. OIG has their own tools, but looking at long length of stay patients, that I think is still one of the big triggers, specifically the portion of patients that are on service over a particular number of days. That is something that is still a pretty good trigger. We could probably do a whole other episode about whether that's the right thing. I tend to think that the amount of audits that are started by just having long length of stay patients has actually caused some problems in the hospice world because I think reasonable hospices set up some extra reviews for long length of stay patients and are pretty quick to discharge them. I get why they do that for business purposes, but it's really hard when the fact that these patients get audited more than others creates a business need for hospices to discharge otherwise really sick and dying patients just because they've been on for quite a while. But that's largely the way the enforcement regime works. A lot of times it's focused on long length of stay patients.

Tom Maxwell (21:46)

Yeah, you know, I look at that in hospices that we work with all the time. Nana's had her worst day, she's been told she's gonna die in the next 180 days or so, right? It's not exactly 180 days, and we've convinced her to elect hospice and she stays on for 180 days and now we review her and Nana's not continuing to progress in her disease and so now we're gonna tell her we're discharging her. Like she's had the worst time of her life, it's probably the worst 180 days of her life thinking she's dying at any time, and now we're gonna say you don't need to be on hospice anymore. And then by the way, a lot of them go back to the hospital and die. And so now it's the worst kind of scenario. All right, let's talk a little bit about the requirement for reporting your data. So I read an article last week and it was actually in the proposed rule that came out that over 30% of the hospices don't report their data. So they take a haircut on payments because they don't report their data. Isn't that a red flag?

Jonathan Porter (22:41)

Yeah, I don't know, Tom. I mean, that to me is something I would need to know way more about. I haven't had any investigations where part of the issue is reporting data. I don't really know about that. I'm still on your last question, thinking in my mind, because I'm with you with those patients. And the issue is, dying looks very different to different people. And sometimes people defy the odds. When they defy the odds, it doesn't mean that you're no longer likely to die in the next six months. Yeah, I'm with you on that. In terms of reporting your data, I don't really know about that. I haven't seen something like that.

Tom Maxwell (23:31)

Yeah, the HOPE and HCI data is the rule that requires you to submit your data, and so you have to submit your data and it includes long length of stay, live discharges, GIPs, weekend visits, all those kinds of things. And you're required to submit this data on every single patient. And if you don't, you get a 4% reduction. And so the government decided, okay, we're going to encourage you to do this. We're going to give you 4% more money or we're going to take away 4% if you don't. And 32% of the hospices don't report their data. And it's really easy to gather that data and report it. So to me, it's a red flag. Like you should be reporting your data, right? Just like if you don't submit your OASIS, you're not going to get paid for a home health claim. You've got to submit your OASIS if you want to get paid. Just like Cole Sorensen, who produces my podcast, if he doesn't submit his expense report, I'm not going to pay him for expenses. It's part of the job. So to me it's a red flag. I'm like, come on guys, you've got to report your data. It's not that hard. And by the way, all the EMRs out there make it really easy for you to roll that up and submit it. So to me that one, I just don't understand it. If it's a government requirement, just like it's a government requirement to document how much time you spend in the home, why would you not document that? They want you to spend more time in the home, that's why they're required to document it. Talk to us about Husch Blackwell out of Georgia. What are you guys primarily focused on on the home health side and then on the hospice side? So what's the business model? When I need you, I call you. What are you guys working on?

Jonathan Porter (25:52)

Yeah, Husch Blackwell, we're a national firm. We've got over 100 healthcare lawyers. We help healthcare organizations in just about everything they do from the legal side. My particular niche is representing those under investigation or in litigation against the Justice Department, sometimes litigation against a whistleblower directly when it's a declined qui tam, something like that. Some other part of my practice is proactive, helping people figure out how to do things in a complete, compliant way. A lot of times that's advice around the anti-kickback statute or some complex compliance issue. Yeah, that's in general what our team does. We've got a small number of healthcare lawyers in Georgia but we're all over the country.

Tom Maxwell (26:43)

Yeah, so Georgia laws are different than California's and there are certain things that are different everywhere. So I'm sure you guys have experts in all these different areas. You mentioned the anti-kickback statute. Explain that one to the listeners. Make sure they understand it. And what are you seeing around the anti-kickback statute?

Jonathan Porter (26:59)

Yeah, the anti-kickback statute, for those who don't know, in virtually every industry in America you can largely profit off of referrals, off of generating business for other people. Healthcare, Congress decided, should be totally different. There were some specific things that were going on in healthcare when the anti-kickback statute was passed. If you go back and read the legislative history, I'm one of the few who's nerdy enough about this stuff to actually go back and read it, there were some very specific fact patterns that Congress was concerned about. They had what they called Medicaid mills where you'd think about strip malls and you'd have all types of different healthcare providers and labs and DMEs and pharmacies all lined up in a row, and you'd have these runners who would apparently go through the entire mill, starting with a physician and then going to a specialist and then going to the DME and all these places and getting money from each one. So for every patient that you brought in, you gave the runner a little bit of money. They called those Medicaid mills. And if you read the legislative history, that's what the anti-kickback statute was designed to stop, these Medicaid mills, people running patients through. That really wasn't illegal until then. I think it probably would violate some medical necessity requirements, but the Justice Department told Congress that they needed something else. And so they created the anti-kickback statute to solve that particular problem. And I think at its core, that's still the way the anti-kickback statute works. I prosecuted a bunch of anti-kickback statute cases at DOJ, and they were all, you know, hey, we'll give you X number of dollars for every lab test that you order or for every back brace that you order, those types of things are pretty clear. You get this amount of dollars if you order this particular thing. That's an anti-kickback statute violation if you do it knowing that what you're doing is wrong. The issue, Tom, is that the anti-kickback statute is being applied in some pretty unique ways these days. There's a case out of Texas right now where the government has said that a free nursing hotline can be a thing that is of benefit to a prescribing provider, which is a pretty significant change from how the anti-kickback statute has been used over time. So there's a lot going on in the anti-kickback statute space where it's being used in ways that no one has ever used it before. There have been some pretty prominent trials recently where you have some extravagant stuff that's going to people who are ordering a particular product, fancy trips, private planes, Super Bowl games, college football championship games. Where it gets really interesting is what happens if you're not on a private jet? What happens if you're just getting someone to fly to your educational seminar at the Toledo airport hotel? Where's the line? The anti-kickback statute doesn't say that the Maui conference is illegal and the Toledo airport conference is fine, but the whole healthcare community has been going to things like the Toledo Airport Hotel in order to get their educational credit and learn about new things for a long time. But the law actually doesn't say that there's a difference between Maui and Toledo. We just sort of treated it that way. And so it's a really interesting area to practice in. I think the anti-kickback statute is one of the big areas that you're gonna see a lot of enforcement in the coming years because it's being changed a little bit in how it's being used.

Tom Maxwell (30:47)

What about in the home health and hospice space? So I get the medical devices and the pharmaceuticals and you know, doctor, if you prescribe X number of these drugs, we take you on this trip or we take you to the Super Bowl. I get all that. But what about in home health? Have you seen any cases in home health or hospice?

Jonathan Porter (31:01)

Yeah, the way that gets scrutinized is around the person making the eligibility determination. There are specific ways that you should be structuring your relationships with people who are, if you're a hospice medical director or a certifying physician for home health, there are particular ways that you should be structuring those things. The way you should not be structuring it is you get paid if you admit people, you don't get paid if you don't. When I went to trial, I think one time on an anti-kickback statute case as a federal prosecutor, I actually drew for the jury arrows with dollars going one way and referrals going the other way, or eligibility determinations going the other way. It's a matter of whether you're paying your physician not just to do his or her job, but to arrive at a particular result. That's the type of situation where you get into some problems. And then you also have to think about your referral sources. So if you've got referral sources and you want to make it really easy for them to refer patients to you by bringing them a bunch of things of value, that's where you start to get in trouble. You want to think about your certifying physicians, you want to think about your referral sources, and you also have to think about your patients. One of the changes that I've seen in the anti-kickback statute is, you know, there's this other law called the beneficiary inducement statute that a lot of people have been thinking about for a long time. Recently DOJ has moved away from using it. The beneficiary inducement statute has all these carve-outs for various things that help patients, but the anti-kickback statute doesn't. So what you're seeing is qui tam relators and DOJ going not through the beneficiary inducement statute, but just saying, if you give things of value to patients, to home health patients or to hospice patients, if you give them something of value, then they could be the person who receives the kickback, I'm putting that in quotations for those who are just listening to the audio. And so that's the way it works. You want to think about your certifying physician, your referral sources, and your patients.

Tom Maxwell (33:15)

So any examples of that you can think of, someone giving something of value to a patient?

Jonathan Porter (33:23)

Yeah, I've got some examples I can't talk about because they're my clients. But think about this. Actually, I had a case when I was at DOJ where a medical practice was advertising that if you came in as a new patient, they'd give you a $50 Amazon gift card or something like that. If you agreed to have a certain procedure, we're going to give you half the money. That's a problem. I had a criminal case when I was at DOJ where a patient went into a pharmacy and said, if you order all of this stuff that I don't need and that has not been prescribed and you give me half the money, then I'll stay quiet. And so they essentially agreed to split the proceeds of healthcare fraud. Even if you didn't have that level of absolute healthcare fraud, giving a patient a portion of the revenue is the type of thing that crosses a pretty big line.

Tom Maxwell (34:33)

Yeah, I'm sure it should be punished under the law. I mean, it's about integrity, all those things. Yeah. All right. Let's talk a little bit about home health. We talk a lot about hospice, but on the home health side, what are the things you're seeing? As it relates to fraud or anti-kickbacks, we talked a little bit about some of them, but you know, eligibility for home health, homebound status is a big one. I know that gets scrutinized a lot, but what are the things you're seeing on the home health side?

Jonathan Porter (34:59)

Yeah, enforcement in home health is still very much around the core issues that you mentioned. I mean, it's eligibility, it's status, it's orders. Like we talked about earlier, DOJ is getting better at using data to spot issues. So they're looking at things like reimbursement per patient or reimbursement per encounter and then reverse engineering the process to figure out why, if it's something like an unusually high number of therapy visits. Sometimes that's a concern with a doctor and figuring out how the certifications are being made. So I wouldn't say there's any one single focus in the home health world, except that DOJ is getting better with data and figuring out why the claims patterns cause whatever issue they're seeing in the data. But I would certainly make sure that your physicians are documenting correctly. A lot of the old ways that you saw in home health enforcement, like cloned notes where doctors were not actually making real determinations about eligibility, I think a lot of people are smart enough to get away from that now, and to be honest AI is going to help a lot of that anyway where you can figure out the right way to accurately state how you're certifying your people. So eligibility and how you're wording your orders, those are some big ones. But I wouldn't say there's any one single trigger when it comes to home health.

Tom Maxwell (36:24)

Yeah, most of the ones I see involve the diagnosis code for the patient. Does the primary diagnosis code match the CTI? Or they have multiple recertifications, five or six, seven recerts on a patient, which shows up in your reimbursement per patient. You know, very little visits on patients, just barely breaking the LUPA threshold on all patients. Those are areas where we see scrutiny as well as the homebound status. I mean, homebound status is a tough one and that's one I wish the government would really look at. In hospice you don't have to be homebound, but in home health you do. And I always talk about the depressed patient that's sad, lonely, scared. The last thing we want that patient to do is be stuck in their home and not be able to leave. And so they really don't qualify for home health, but they do qualify for home health because they need someone to check on them and treat them and take care of them. But we're now telling Nana who's lonely to stay home and don't go anywhere. So we're just going to make her more lonely. And then she's going to call 911 and go to the hospital. And she's not lonely anymore. She's at the hospital, which is the worst place for her to be. Yeah, it's a wild time. I think it's getting harder and harder and harder. And the fraud itself, you know, in California, Florida, Texas, all these places where you hear all the fraud, it's just giving the industry a bad reputation. I mean, we're in the national news now. And by the way, most people that are 65 or older all watch the news at home, they sit in front of the TV and watch it. People that are my generation or younger get their news from the internet or Twitter or whatever, X or whatever you call it now. But they're sitting there listening and thinking hospice is bad, hospice is bad. And that's unfortunate because it's the one thing that patients deserve. It's the benefit you've paid for your whole entire life. Nobody should die alone. You should die under hospice and get the appropriate care and social workers and chaplains and aides that you need. And by the way, they cover all the medications and DME and care. And so you should be able to die in your own home surrounded by your family. But there's such scrutiny happening that it's really giving the industry a bad name. And I know the industry is trying to fight it off and trying to explain that the good guys are really doing the right thing. But it's pretty bizarre. Whistleblower cases are growing and threatening both home health and hospice, with relators filing a lot of cases. You deal with these a lot. Talk to me about those. What do you usually hear? Is it usually someone being told to do something wrong or what's usually the case for these whistleblower cases?

Jonathan Porter (38:41)

Yeah, so like we talked about earlier, Tom, whistleblowers play an outsized role in healthcare enforcement because of their ability to launch a whole federal investigation. I would say, Tom, the most common whistleblower in my experience is a disgruntled former employee. Disgruntled former employees are a bit of a mixed bag to DOJ because they help get evidence of knowledge of wrongdoing within the organization. That's a really important thing that DOJ needs to prove. Remember we talked earlier about how it's not necessarily about did you do right or wrong. It's did you know that you were doing right or wrong? A whistleblower can say, no, you understood that you were doing wrong. Here's the board meeting minutes or the email or the text message where you said that what you're doing was wrong. So whistleblowers can help do that. But they're also jaded. So DOJ is typically careful with jaded whistleblowers who have an axe to grind. So like I said, they're a bit of a mixed bag. The best whistleblowers are usually senior employees who don't come across as angry. There have been some really successful whistleblowers who were C-suite executives who tried to fix problems from within and then left when they couldn't. Those are really powerful whistleblowers, but those are rare. There was a whistleblower in Louisiana recently who was a current employee of a hospice and who the FBI then wired up after they filed the qui tam, wired up for an extended period of time to record meetings within the hospice. That hospice owner ended up not just with False Claims Act problems, but a criminal conviction. So more and more you are seeing current employees, but I think that's pretty rare. Most of the time it's a former employee. More and more though, what we're seeing is non-employee whistleblowers. You're seeing patients file qui tams against some sort of provider that they think did them wrong. You're seeing competitors file qui tams. I think that's an interesting development. What you're also seeing is data mining companies serving as whistleblowers. And that's a bit of a new one. Just a couple of weeks ago, DOJ announced this program where they're going to vet data mining companies that serve as whistleblowers. It's really interesting. I don't really know that they're doing a whole lot in the healthcare space yet, but they're doing a lot on the COVID fraud space. These data mining companies figure out who's eligible and who is not. I think just as our technology gets better and better, you're going to see a lot more data mining companies that are going to file qui tams and try to get a portion of the government's recovery as a reward. I would prefer that the government invest in all of those gee-whiz technologies in order to find people that are committing fraud rather than a qui tam relator that is actually just a data mining company doing all of that. But you know, it's an interesting development. It's going to keep people like me very busy fighting off these data mining companies that are going to try to allege fraud. Yeah, whistleblowers play a really big role and they come from all forms.

Tom Maxwell (44:08)

Yeah, the AI world is going to make this all super interesting. I mean, we still haven't got to the bottom of, if the AI says this is the care plan, the frequency, the number of visits and you follow that, who's in trouble there? Right. The nurse is ultimately responsible, the agency is ultimately responsible for the care. AI is making a suggestion for them. But I think you're going to see some stuff around that as well. All right. Let's talk a little bit about self-disclosing. So if an agency figures out they have a problem, and it's happened before. You go back and you look at claims, or you acquire somebody and start deep diving into the claims. You say, yeah, some of these claims are probably not right. We should self-disclose. Okay, we made a mistake here. And you self-disclose to the government. Can you come out ahead in that? I mean, it's the right thing to do. It's what you're supposed to do. You should do it. But what is it? How does the Department of Justice look at those? Do they look at them differently than a whistleblower case or just a flat out fraud case?

Jonathan Porter (45:04)

Yeah, that's actually a really big hot topic within the white collar defense community at large. I'm told that the answer throughout most of the last 50 years was that self-disclosing was almost never worth it. There were all these stories of companies that walked into DOJ, self-disclosed some bad stuff, and then still got hammered just as bad as if they'd been caught red-handed. I think DOJ heard those stories too. And so in the last decade, there has really been a concerted effort to change all of that. So I'd say now the calculus is more self-disclosure friendly. To me, I'm going to walk clients through the pros and cons of each, but it depends on what the conduct at issue is. It depends on whether you've had a noisy exit recently from someone who could become a whistleblower, how obvious the conduct is. Is this just a disagreement? Is this someone where there's a person making the noisy exit who's convinced that there was fraud, but you and a bunch of other people in the company don't think it's fraud? So it depends on a bunch of things. I think you've got to just walk the client through the pros and cons of the self-disclosure, but we're definitely in a spot where it makes sense for at least some people to go ahead and make a self-disclosure. I'll note that there was one case recently where the company self-disclosed not to DOJ but directly to CMS and DOJ gave them credit for that. That's not the worst idea ever depending on your situation, some sort of a self-disclosure not to law enforcement but to CMS. So there are some creative things that you can do that don't necessarily open you up to just a really catastrophic result that allegedly happened decades ago. So there are some creative things there, but I think it depends on what situation the home health or hospice or whatever type of healthcare provider is in. There are a lot of different ways it could go depending on the facts.

Tom Maxwell (47:15)

Yeah, I heard about one, it's been five or six years ago, where a physician was referring patients and he was part of an anti-kickback scheme. The agency really didn't know this was going on. It was between him and a sales rep and they discovered it and so they self-disclosed it. It was only five patients but they self-disclosed it and the government actually was very positive around it. They were like, hey, thank you for doing this. We're gonna investigate it. They went after the doctor and they took the money back from the agency. Again, it was only five home health patients but it was the right thing to do to self-disclose, because if you tried to hide it or brush it under the rug then you're essentially proving yourself guilty as well. And so they were the ones that actually turned the doctor in and figured it out. They fired the sales rep, of course, and it all worked out. Yeah, there's always a challenge around that. All right. Artificial intelligence is starting to show up in clinical documentation and building workflows across all home health and hospice. What new enforcement risks should operators be worried about right now around artificial intelligence?

Jonathan Porter (48:15)

Yeah, we could do a whole hour on just AI. I mean, it's a really, really big thing. There are a thousand different AI enforcement risks in healthcare. On the simple side, ambient listening devices to generate medical records are becoming more and more common, but you've got to be careful about how you're prompting that. Someone at some point is going to use AI to shade notes to support particular types of eligibility. I think DOJ and whistleblowers would say that that's no different than cloned notes. I don't know that I agree with that, but it's certainly risky if you say, look, I want you, AI, to listen to our encounter and then try to find a reason for how this person is eligible for X and Y and Z. That I think presents a bunch of problems. Coding prompts is another area that I see as risky. It's one thing to use AI as clinical support, you know, catching things like appointments without a prior authorization or when a hospice patient's prescription is about to run out, those types of things. But what happens when your AI-driven clinical support brings up a prompt that says, could this patient benefit from GIP in order to run up payments? There are a thousand others, but those are the ones that hit my mind first in terms of what could be really risky in AI with home health and hospice.

Tom Maxwell (49:37)

As a guy that's been in the AI business for a long time and built products using all that, we've always said it's a clinical co-pilot. And we don't even use the term artificial intelligence because it's not artificial, it's real. And so if I'm asking a nurse to read a 40-page discharge plan from the hospital or a 40-page documentation from the hospital, it's really not possible for her to read all that, understand it, digest it, and make a clinical decision around it. But if I use AI just to pull out the key points and then use that to help in her documentation, making sure she followed up that, you know, Nana has a wound here, Nana has this historical disease or she has these allergies or these medications, that's a co-pilot. It's not giving you clinical guidance around what to do or how to do it with that patient. We're always still going to make sure that the clinician is involved. All we're trying to do is serve up documentation to her to make it easier. Summarize the note. And so I think that, in my opinion, is very beneficial. If you start using AI to replace a clinician or a clinician's decisions, then I think it becomes a real challenge. So there is going to be a lot of scrutiny around it. The ambient listening side of it is really interesting to me because I think you can do ambient listening, you can do better documentation, cleaner documentation, faster documentation, make it easier, have 100% grammatically correct notes with no spelling errors, those kinds of things, but you still have to have a clinician review it and sign off on it and make sure that they're doing it. And rightfully so, right? It's their name, it's their signature at the bottom of that page. We're just trying to help them go faster, better, and quicker. But there are going to be a lot of lawsuits around AI in the future, I think. I've seen some that are doing 100% auto coding and they're coding with upcodes and all those. It's one thing to say, hey, you missed these codes in your documentation. It's another thing to say, hey, here's how you code for better financial outcomes. I think it's an area that we've got to spend a lot of time on and there are going to be a lot of lawyers looking at it for sure. All right. So for all the home health and hospice leaders that are listening right now, the operators that are out there running agencies that have not overhauled their compliance programs in the last three to five years, what are the three things that they need to address immediately?

Jonathan Porter (51:44)

Yeah, good question, Tom. So one, I'd say figure out your highest risk patients. Is there a particular homebound rationale that you're concerned with? Are there long length of stay patients? Figure out your highest risk patients. Two, I would say set up an extra layer of review for those high risk patients. We talked earlier about how that's sort of a standard thing that at least hospices do, to set up an extra layer of review. I would say that does not mean that you are presumptively going to discharge someone who's a long length of stay, but just make sure that you've got your documentation in order. Like we were talking about earlier, Tom, it would be a shame if people thought that long length of stay meant you have to discharge them or should discharge them. I would just say if you've got long length of stay patients or someone where you've got some concern on eligibility for home health, just make sure you've got your documentation right. That's all your extra layer of review has to do. Just know that you're going to get the scrutiny and stand by your decisions. The third, I would say, work with your medical professionals to make sure they're documenting things the right way. A lot of times when there's scrutiny about things like long length of stay or eligibility in home health, it's not necessarily about what was right and wrong. It's about what's on the paper. And so if you can make sure that your medical professionals know, hey, we're at this number of months or years mark and the FAST score keeps changing or the weight keeps dropping, make sure you're documenting the subtle things that continue to show progression of disease. I think some providers might just say, okay, well, I say that they're eligible, I shouldn't have to document gradual progression of disease. No, you have to show it. We're in an era where you have to show your work. It's like the old middle school math test problem. Show your work. If you don't show your work, you're not getting credit. So just show and explain how you're seeing gradual progression of disease. And that's not even a matter of whether they're eligible or not. If you think that they're eligible, you just have to show that they're eligible by documenting things the right way. And sometimes you just need to train your medical professionals on how to do that the right way so that what's going on in their mind is being recorded on the paper.

Tom Maxwell (54:07)

That's right. So if they think Nana still belongs on hospice or in home health, make sure you're documenting appropriately and make sure your forms and documentation require that. Is Nana still homebound? Let's ask that question at every recertification. Is she still homebound? If she's not, she's not eligible for the home health benefit. She may be eligible for a different level of care. Make sure that we're documenting that correctly and we should check ourselves on that for sure. And then you should create the compliance programs that review those charts and make sure they're right. I agree with that. What separates a compliance program that actually protects an agency from one that just looks good on paper?

Jonathan Porter (54:43)

Yeah, good question. I mean, Tom, you'd be stunned how many people think compliance is just the right binders on a shelf. I think that was the way that healthcare compliance was at one point, you know, sign up for my compliance program and I'll send you all the binders. That's just not the way it works anymore. You know, DOJ is full of leaders who were sometimes federal prosecutors and they went to private practice or in-house and then came back in the law enforcement role. They understand what the difference is between binders on a shelf and an actual compliance program with teeth. One of the things that I like to do with clients is to make sure that when we're looking at our compliance program, we've got examples of complaints that came in and we can show what we did with them. It doesn't mean that you have to agree with the complaint every single time, but if you can show the steps that you took to actually investigate the thing, and you made an outcome decision, and you informed the person of what the outcome is, that's most of the job of a great compliance program. It's to at least document that you're doing the work and you're coming to some sort of a decision. There are a lot of people out there who don't do anything like that. They don't have a log of complaints. They don't have a log of what they did in response to complaints. It's really hard for people like me to do their job when all of a sudden there's scrutiny and you can't tell me what happened in your compliance program and why it happened. So yeah, having a log is a really good starting point, here are the complaints that we received and here is what we did about them. But a lot of people don't have the log, and sometimes they'll say something that doesn't happen to my clients since my clients all have the log, but I'm told that other people in healthcare get to a spot where they say, okay, we don't actually have a log because we've never had any compliance complaints, so we're perfect. That's a problem. Zero compliance complaints means that you're not making sure that people know how to voice their compliance concerns. So make sure that you actually are receiving compliance complaints from people because if you're not, I think DOJ is going to say you just didn't make it available in the way that you should have.

Tom Maxwell (56:52)

Sure. Yeah, it's amazing to me, and we help a lot of agencies with QA and compliance, it's amazing to me how many people don't have good follow through on all of these. You should follow through on every one of them. You should log it and you're going to have problems. You're going to have that situation where someone had a bad day or someone said something that they shouldn't have said. I always think back to an agency that I was working with that had a patient that we knew really well. And the nurse went in and said, you know, I'm really busy today. I don't have a lot of time to spend with you. And the lady complained and they didn't do anything about it. And they got in trouble for it. And I'm like, you have to respond to these. You have to. So you're going to have complaints. It's how you address the complaint, how you follow through, and the outcome of that complaint and then the teaching around it, right? If we had that problem, okay, let's go talk to the nurses and say, hey, don't be disclosing to the patients how busy you are and how little time you have with them. That's not the right thing to do. They want you to feel like they're your only patient. The education and training around when you have a complaint and how you take that to the organization is super important. Then make sure you document in the policies and procedures that clinicians follow how to address these things. Then make it easy for patients. If a patient needs to complain, you want to know about it. If we're not doing the right thing for somebody, I want to know about it and I want to address it, solve it, fix it, and correct it. That's the most important piece of it. I see that all the time. All right. If you could change one thing about how the government approaches home health or hospice enforcement, what would it be?

Jonathan Porter (58:21)

Yeah, it would be what we talked about before, sort of ignore the relator inclination to go after the deep pockets and instead go after the bad guys. You know, a big portion of the way our system is set up, you've got an entire civil fraud division in DC. You've got groups within every US Attorney's office whose job is to respond to False Claims Act qui tams and go launch investigations based on what relators want you to launch. I would say let's make sure we're going after the real bad guys first. We're spending a lot of resources just responding to what relators want DOJ to do. I would say let's put the resources toward going and finding all of those people that are in the news. The instances on YouTube, like you were talking about Tom, where you go out and you see nothing there. It's just a UPS box and they're supposedly running a multi-million dollar healthcare organization out of that UPS box. If I had the ability to step in and change things, I would say let's go do that and be less responsive to the relators and their inclination to go after the deep pockets.

Tom Maxwell (59:37)

Yeah, for sure. I wish we could spend all of our time and effort on those people and not on the people that are trying to do the right thing. All right, you've sat across from people at their worst moments in their professional lives, both as a prosecutor and a defense attorney. What do you want home health and hospice leaders to walk away from this conversation knowing before it gets to that point?

Jonathan Porter (59:58)

Yeah, Tom, you know, investigations are common in healthcare and they're becoming more and more common. That means there's a good chance that a lot of our listeners right now will be involved in an investigation at some point in their career in healthcare. I would say don't panic. The big takeaway to me is don't panic. Being involved in an investigation doesn't mean that you've done something wrong. A lot of times it means that there's some gray area and a relator filed something that is trying to scrutinize a decision that you made in a gray area. So don't panic. If you find yourself with a civil investigative demand or a subpoena in the mail or an agent on your doorstep, don't panic. Don't feel like you need to go explain yourself right off the bat. What you need to do before you get the CID is to do what you think is right and write down the things that you think are right. If there's a gray area, write down why you're doing what you're doing and make sure you're documenting on the front end. And then after you get that civil investigative demand or subpoena, pick a good defense lawyer to defend you, someone who knows what they're doing in this world, and then let the defense lawyer be the one to defend you. You don't need to go off and make a bunch of statements and try to explain yourself to someone before you get the lawyer. Start by getting the lawyer and then let the lawyer be the buffer between you and the people asking the questions.

Tom Maxwell (1:01:27)

Yeah, stop talking so much, that's true. Use your ears, not your mouth. All right, for an operator or compliance officer who just finished listening and realized that they may have some exposure or wants to take a look at their programs, or in the event of an emergency, how do they get in touch with you and your team?

Jonathan Porter (1:01:44)

Yeah, well thank you for that. I appreciate the ability to put in a plug. So yeah, you can call me. You can email me at jonathan.porter@huschblackwell.com. You can Google me, Jonathan Porter, Husch Blackwell, Jonathan Porter healthcare lawyer, and it will probably bring up my information as well. But yeah, call me or email me. I'm happy to talk with folks about what their concerns are. You know, a lot of people, I get a lot of calls from people saying, I just heard about someone doing something and we're doing something that is tangentially related to that. Do I have a problem? I'm happy to talk through those types of things with people. I think a lot of things that people bring to me can be fixed with documentation on the front end, so I'm happy to walk people through what that looks like on the front end. I love counseling people about how to not get in trouble with DOJ. That's actually a really fun thing for me to do. A little bit less fun when I'm helping them respond to the crisis, but still something that I enjoy doing. So yeah, that's the way they get in touch with me.

Tom Maxwell (1:02:55)

Well, Jonathan, thank you so much for giving us all your guidance, advice, and direction, and for sharing some of your historical stories. You were a special guest that we really wanted to get on the show. And the timing fortunately was perfect with all the stuff going on in California and Texas and Arizona and everywhere else. But we appreciate your advice and direction and advise the listeners, if you get into a situation, if you don't call Jonathan and his team, make sure you get a hold of the right lawyer, someone that knows what they're doing in the home health or hospice space and has experience doing it. Thank you sir for coming.

Jonathan Porter (1:03:27)

Tom, thanks for having me. This was fun.

All episodes